hot out the oven

FRESH SLICES

Cup-and-char pepperoni, homemade everything, and a hot-honey streak. Your neighborhood slice shop — twice over.

Canandaigua, NY Palmyra, NY
Combo Deals

More pie,
less dough.

Three ways to feed the table for less. Mix it your way — every combo's built for sharing.

Best value 01 2 Slices
& a beverage
$12
02 12" Sub, chips
& a drink
$16
Game day 03 Lg cheese pizza,
36 wings & 2L soda
$50
Specialty Pizza

The pies worth
the wait.

TheGrandma

House marinara, mozzarella, roasted garlic and torn basil. Square, crispy-bottomed, the way Sunday should taste.

MarinaraRoasted garlicBasil

TheMag Pie

Butter-garlic sauce, mozzarella, ricotta, roasted garlic and spinach. A white pie that doesn't whisper.

WhiteRicottaSpinach

ThePestroni

Basil pesto, mozzarella, cup-and-char pepperoni, finished with a drizzle of hot honey. Sweet, salty, a little dangerous.

PestoCup & charHot honey
12" Small+$2 / topping$13
20" Large+$3 / topping$24
16" Siciliansquare · +$3 / topping$18
Build your own Cup & Char PepperoniSausageMeatballCrispy / Grilled ChickenBaconTraditional PepperoniBlack OlivesJalapeñosMushroomsRed OnionRicottaRoasted Red PeppersBroccoliSpinach
By the Slice

Grab & go.

Cheese or Pepperoni
hot & fresh, all day
$5
Specialty Slice
grandma · mag pie · pestroni
$6
Calzone
mozzarella · +$2 per topping
$13
Chicken Wings

12 ct · $12

Golden-fried and tossed in your choice of sauce:

Werewolf-Style Wings

A sweet-and-spicy sauce built on Calabrian chili, then finished on the grill. Order under a full moon.

The Whole Menu

Everything else
we make by hand.

Find Us

Two shops.
One family.

Canandaigua
395 S. Main Street, Canandaigua, NY 14424
585·396·2840
Mon – Thu11am – 8pm
Fri – Sat11am – 10pm
Sunday12pm – 7pm
Palmyra
505 W. Main Street, Palmyra, NY 14522
315·502·0108
7 Days a Week11am – 10pm
Kitchenopen late
Slices'til close